A former Evansville fire lieutenant is suing the city in federal court, claiming the department fired him earlier this year after he made an off-duty social media post in support of Immigration and Customs Enforcement. The allegations in the complaint have not been proven in court.
John Wesley Alexander, a third-generation firefighter who joined the department in 2016 and was promoted to lieutenant in 2020, filed the lawsuit on Nov. 5 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana. The complaint names the City of Evansville as the sole defendant and brings seven counts, including First Amendment retaliation and viewpoint discrimination, disability discrimination and discriminatory termination, and retaliation for requesting a reasonable accommodation.
According to the complaint, Alexander wrote the comments in February in the comments section of an Eyewitness News story about a federal judge's ruling in an ICE custody case. The complaint argues he wrote them off duty, on his own account, without identifying his rank or employer and without using city equipment, as a participant in a public discussion. He describes the post as a lapse during a mental health crisis brought on by post-traumatic stress disorder, and says he later completed residential treatment and was cleared by a treating physician to return to work by May 6.
Fire Chief Tony Knight suspended Alexander for five days in March and recommended that he be fired. Alexander offered to accept a voluntary reduction in rank and the suspension instead, which the chief declined. The Evansville Fire Merit Commission finalized his termination on May 26, voting 4-1, with commission president Mike Dickinson dissenting.
The complaint also alleges that other department employees received coaching or lesser discipline for their own speech, and asks a judge to rule the city violated his rights, with reinstatement, damages and back pay among the relief sought. A spokeswoman for Mayor Stephanie Terry said the city had not yet received nor reviewed the lawsuit, and no hearings had been scheduled as of Wednesday.







